Since the engineered bacteria cannot quickly gain a numerical advantage in the sewage environment, we hope that the AHL enzymes secreted by the engineered bacteria can more efficiently degrade multiple AHL compounds. Therefore, optimization of the wild-type AHL enzymes is required to achieve higher catalytic efficiency.
On the other hand, antimicrobial peptides(AMP) used to kill sulfate reducing bacteria(SRB) lack selectivity, and there is still host bacterial toxicity in direct secretion. Therefore, we hope to design a carrier targeting the SRB microenvironment in the form of a fusion protein,a chimeric antimicrobial peptide to achieve specific killing of SRB.
Fig.1 optimization of AHL enzymes
Fig.2 AMP fusion protein release strategy
The directed evolution of enzymes provides an effective means of obtaining advantageous mutants, but it often requires a significant amount of time and effort to construct a mutant library and carry out screening. On the other hand, semi-rational design involves saturated mutagenesis of a select few specific residues as targets based on the protein's structure-function relationship, greatly reducing the workload for screening.
AiiA and AidH are both AHL lactonases, which catalyze the hydrolysis and ring-opening of AHL molecules, disrupting their activity as quorum sensing molecules. This disruption effectively interferes with quorum sensing in sulfate-reducing bacterial populations.
Fig.3 Reaction of AiiA and AidH
We analyzed the structures of AiiA and AidH and found:
(1) AiiA belongs to a class of metal-dependent lactonases, where several histidine residues in the active pocket coordinate with metals, thereby conferring enzymatic activity.
Fig.4 The structure of AiiA with two Zinc atoms
(2) AidH is not a metal-dependent enzyme but rather a member of the α/β hydrolase enzyme family. (Mei, Gui-Ying et al. 2010) Based on multiple sequence alignments of AidH with its close relatives QqlG and QqlM, as well as literature research, it has been found that the catalytic center of AidH consists of a catalytic triad composed of three amino acids (S102, E219, H248). These three amino acids are highly conserved in the lactonase enzyme family.
Fig.5 The structure of AidH
Fig.6 Multiple Alignment between AidH、QqlG、Qqlm
(3) The catalytic mechanism of AidH involves the hydroxyl group of serine at position 102 acting as a nucleophilic agent, attacking the carbonyl carbon atom of the lactone. The lone pair electrons on the nitrogen of histidine at position 248 enhance the nucleophilicity of the serine hydroxyl group. Additionally, the carboxylate anion of glutamate at position 219 forms a hydrogen bond with the nitrogen atom on histidine, further increasing the electron density on the nitrogen atom. (Gao, Ang et al. 2013)
Fig.7 The catalytic mechanism of AidH
Since AiiA is a metalloenzyme, zinc ion coordination is a necessary condition to maintain its activity, following a general strategy of enzyme site-directed mutagenesis.(Ben Mabrouk, Sameh et al. 2011)
Considering introducing new salt bridges into the AiiA enzyme molecule is a normal way to enhance its stability. In accordance with the aforementioned mutation strategy, we selected to randomly mutate the 65th amino acid (asparagine) and the 195th amino acid (serine) of the AiiA protein and constructed a mutant library. As salt bridges need to be formed, we used basic amino acids to construct the mutant library.
We selected the following five mutants and then constructed three-dimensional models. For point mutations, the accuracy of homology modeling is already high enough. Therefore, we chose SWISS-Model to model our mutant proteins. We used PyMOL to analyze the RMSD values of the mutants and used CBdock2 software (Yang Liu, et al. 2022) to dock these five mutants with AHL molecules (C6-C12).
Amino acid mutation type | RMSD |
---|---|
N65K | 0.195 |
N65R | 0.195 |
N65H | 0.195 |
T195K | 0.195 |
T195R | 0.195 |
T195H | 0.195 |
Table.1 Mutation in AiiA and RMSD compared with WT
Cavity volume (ų) | C6-HSL | C8-HSL | C10-HSL | C12-HSL | |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
WT | 707 | -6.5 | -6.7 | -6.5 | -6.2 |
N65K | 923 | -6.4 | -6.6 | -6.8 | -6.8 |
N65R | 991 | -6.3 | -6.5 | -6.6 | -6.7 |
N65H | 923 | -6.3 | -6.9 | -6.8 | -7.1 |
T195K | 922 | -6.4 | -6.6 | -6.6 | -6.7 |
T195R | 924 | -6.4 | -6.5 | -6.6 | -6.6 |
T195H | 922 | -6.4 | -6.6 | -6.6 | -6.7 |
Table.2 Vina score and Cavity volume of all AiiA mutants
Combining the RMSD values and docking results, we found that point mutations did not affect the enzyme's active center, and the binding energy of each mutant with the substrate was similar to the wild type. Considering that the 70th amino acid, which is close in spatial position to the 65th amino acid of AiiA, is glutamic acid, and the 236th amino acid, which is close to the 195th amino acid of AiiA, is aspartic acid, both amino acids are acidic. To form salt bridges, we initially selected N65K and T195R as mutation candidates and entrusted the wet lab team to characterize and verify the activity of these mutants.
Fig.8 vital residues in AiiA(N65,E70,T195,D236)
AidH belongs to the α/β hydrolase enzyme family. Based on the catalytic mechanism depicted in the diagram and the three-dimensional structure of AidH with the substrate, we have identified that the side chain of the 147th alanine residue might obstruct the binding of the substrate to the active pocket. (Zhang, Yixin et al. 2023) Therefore, we have chosen to mutate the 147th amino acid of AidH to alanine with a smaller steric hindrance and leucine with larger steric hindrance.
Fig.9 AidH's Substrate Binding Pocket
Based on the above, through semi-rational design, we have screened out 4 mutants: AiiA: N65K, T195R; AidH: A147G, A147V.
However, the success of the semi-rational design still requires validation through wet lab experiments. Therefore, we have entrusted the wet lab experimental team to assist us in constructing the mutant enzymes and verifying their activity.
In many cases, directly expressing antimicrobial peptides(AMP) in Escherichia coli can be toxic to the host bacterium. (Yong Yang, Dejun Jin, Weiwei Yu, et al. 2017) Therefore, one common approach in prokaryotic expression systems is to produce antimicrobial peptides in the form of fusion proteins,because it didn’t inactivate AMP if its’ carbon terminal is extant. Additionally, since we do not want the freely released antimicrobial peptides to become toxic to the host bacteria after secretion, it is crucial to have a responsive antimicrobial peptide release strategy tailored to the specific microenvironment of the SRB.
We investigated the physicochemical characteristics of the SRB microenvironment and found that due to the extreme anaerobic conditions of SRB, the redox potential in its microenvironment is very low, and it generates numerous thiol compounds (Shi, Xuan et al. 2020) High concentrations of thiol compounds and an extremely low redox potential suggest that we can design a responsive antimicrobial peptide release strategy based on disulfide bond reduction. Therefore, we designed a degradable linker based on disulfide bonds as the fusion protein linker, enabling the release of antimicrobial peptides in response to the SRB microenvironment. This allows the antimicrobial peptides to accumulate in the SRB microenvironment, achieving a targeted effect.
Fig.10 The redox potential of SRB microenvironment (Chen, Xiaoying et al. 2010)
Fig.11 Degradable disulfide bond linker (Mirdita, Milot et al. 2022)
Therefore, we selected the glycosidase DspB and AidH as the carrier of antimicrobial peptides because both enzymes are designed to secret into the extracellular,which means it can bring AMP as the same time, and designed the linker to be sensitive to TEV protease(which can recognize EQLYFQG). Therefore, the entire action process of our fusion protein is as follows:
Therefore, the complete amino acid sequence is as follows:
DspB-SS Linker(with TEV recognition site)-Bactenecin(Bac):
MKKAITLFTLLCAVLLSFSTATYANAMDLPKKESGLTLDIARRFYTVDTIKQFIDTIHQAGGTFLHLHFSDHENYALESSYLEQREENATEKNGTYFNPKTNKPFLTYKQLNEIIYYAKERNIEIVPEVDSPNHMTAIFDLLTLKHGKEYVKGLKSPYIAEEIDINNPEAVEVIKTLIGEVIYIFGHSSRHFHIGGDEFSYAVENNHEFIRYVNTLNDFINSKGLITRVWNDGLIKNNLSELNKNIEITYWSYDGDAQAKEDIQYRREIRADLPELLANGFKVLNYNSYYLYFVPKSGSNIHNDGKYAAEDVLNNWTLGKWDGKNSSNHVQNTQNIIGSSLSIWGERSSALNEQTIQQASKNLLKAVIQKTNDPKSH GCP EQLYFQG CGILKR RLCRIVVIRVCR
AidH-SS Linker(with TEV recognition site)-Indolicidin(Ind):
MTINYHELETSHGRIAVRESEGEGAPLLMIHGNSSSGAIFAPQLEGEIGKKWRVIAPDLPGHGKSTDAIDPDRSYSMEGYADAMTEVMQQLGIADAVVFGWSLGGHIGIEMIARYPEMRGLMITGTPPVAREEVGQGFKSGPDMALAGQEIFSERDVESYARSTCGEPFEASLLDIVARTDGRARRIMFEKFGSGTGGNQRDIVAEAQLPIAVVNGRDEPFVELDFVSKVKFGNLWEGKTHVIDNAGHAPFREAPAEFDAYLARFIRDCTQ GC EQLYFQG CGILKR ILPWKWPWWPWRR
Among them, EQLYFQG is a sensitive sequence for TEV protease, which can be degraded by TEV protease.
We used colabfold[10] to model our protein, The results indicate that the lDDT score of the antimicrobial peptide segment is very low, suggesting that the antimicrobial peptide segment is irregularly folded. However, what may actually affect the antimicrobial peptide activity is the post-cleavage structure, as there are additional amino acids on its N-terminus. Therefore, we calculated the RMSD value between the cleaved fused antimicrobial peptide and the original antimicrobial peptide. The results show that after cleavage, the structure of Bac remains essentially the same, indicating a greater likelihood of retaining activity. In contrast, the conformation of Ind undergoes significant changes, which may have a certain impact on its activity.
DspB-Bac |
AidH-Ind |
Fig.12 IDDT value of fusion proteins
Fig.13 Alignment of AMP and Carrier-AMP(digested by TEV protease)
RMSD value | |
---|---|
Bac and DspB-Bac | 0.253 |
Ind and AidH-Ind | 1.588 |
Table.3 RMSD value between AMP and Carrier-AMP (digested by TEV)
Mei GY, Yan XX, Turak A, Luo ZQ, Zhang LQ. AidH, an alpha/beta-hydrolase fold family member from an Ochrobactrum sp. strain, is a novel N-acylhomoserine lactonase. Appl Environ Microbiol. 2010 Aug;76(15):4933-42.
Gao A, Mei GY, Liu S, Wang P, Tang Q, Liu YP, Wen H, An XM, Zhang LQ, Yan XX, Liang DC. High-resolution structures of AidH complexes provide insights into a novel catalytic mechanism for N-acyl homoserine lactonase. Acta Crystallogr D Biol Crystallogr. 2013 Jan;69(Pt 1):82-91.
Mabrouk SB, Aghajari N, Ali MB, Messaoud EB, Juy M, Haser R, Bejar S. Enhancement of the thermostability of the maltogenic amylase MAUS149 by Gly312Ala and Lys436Arg substitutions. Bioresource Technology, 2011, 102(2): 1740-1746.
Yang Liu, et al. CB-Dock2: improved protein-ligand blind docking by integrating cavity detection, docking, and homologous template fitting. Nucleic Acids Research, 2022.Xiaocong Yang, et al. FitDock: protein-ligand docking by template fitting. Briefings In Bioinformatics, 2022.
Zhang Y, Wei W, Wen H, Cheng Z, Mi Z, Zhang J, Liu X, Fan X. Targeting Multidrug-Recalcitrant Pseudomonas aeruginosa Biofilms: Combined-Enzyme Treatment Enhances Antibiotic Efficacy. Antimicrob Agents Chemother. 2023 Jan 24;67(1):e0135822.
Yong Yang, Dejun Jin, Weiwei Yu, et al. Fusion expression strategy of antimicrobial peptides in Escherichia coli. Hubei Agricultural Sciences, 2017, 56(15): 2801-2805, 2810.
Shi X, Gao G, Tian J, Wang XC, Jin X, Jin P. Symbiosis of sulfate-reducing bacteria and methanogenic archaea in sewer systems. Environ Int. 2020 Oct;143:105923.
Chen X, Bai Y, Zaro JL, Shen WC. Design of an in vivo cleavable disulfide linker in recombinant fusion proteins. Biotechniques. 2010 Jul;49(1):513-8.
Mirdita M, Schütze K, Moriwaki Y, Heo L, Ovchinnikov S, Steinegger M. ColabFold: Making protein folding accessible to all. Nature Methods, 2022