In order to complete Project "STAND UP", we have been working on the development in a more engineering way by implementing the Design, Build, Test, Learn Cycle (: DBTL Cycle). In this page, we will introduce how we have tackled various problems by implementing the DBTL Cycle from the aspects of Wet and Dry.

CFNT: Cell Fluorescence Neutralization Test measures the amount of neutralizing antibodies in the subject's serum as described in Description and Design. As described in Description and Design, CFNT measures the number of neutralizing antibodies in the subject's serum. Since the number of neutralizing antibodies is quantified by the ratio of green to red fluorescence, infection-detecting cells are one of the most important elements in CFNT. The quality of infection detection cells should be maintained to guarantee the sensitivity and specificity of CFNT when it is implemented in society in the future. In other words, infection-detecting cell lines should be established, and we have performed several DBTL cycles for this purpose.

  • Design

    In iGEM 2022, TokyoTech attempted to establish infection detection cell lines by two methods: Electroporation and Lipofection. Infection detecting cells were co-transfected with linearized pCAGGS N-Cre DNA:BBa_K4419025 and linearized pMC1 neo-polyA (Fig.1). The selection with G418 was planned for the gene Neo^R from pMC1 neo-polyA, but transformants could not be obtained because the concentration of G418 was too high. Therefore, we planned an experiment to determine the optimal G418 concentration to obtain transformants.

    fig:1
    Fig.1 | How to create infection-detecting cells Linearized pCAGGS N-Cre and pMC1 neo-polyA are co-transfected by Electroporation. The gene circuit is then incorporated into the cell genome by random integration. The resulting transformants (infection-detecting cells) are selected by applying selection pressure with G418.
  • Build

    To determine the optimal G418 concentration to obtain transformants, PULSE was added to Vero cells in the Electroporator and cultured for 1 week in medium graded for G418 concentration. (Experiments 221123~221207) The results showed that G418 900 µg/mL with 30% Confluency after 1 week was optimal for screening (Fig.2).

    fig2
    Fig.2 | Vero cells cultured in DMEM+10%FBS+G418 as medium for 1 week G418 concentrations are 0, 100, 300, 600, 900, 1200, and 1500 µg/mL, respectively. The white scale bar represents 200 µm.
  • Ttest

    Electroporation of pCAGGS N-Cre and pMC1 neo-polyA (Both are straightened) with G418 900 µg/mL was performed again as determined in Build and selection with G418. (Experiments 221213-221225) Selections were made for 13 days, but cultured cells did not form colonies and no fluorescence was observed (Fig.3).

    fig3
    Fig.3 | Photograph of Vero cells electroporated with pCAGGS N-Cre and pMC1 neo-polyA and normal Vero cells selected with G418 G418 concentration was 900 µg/mL, selection was performed for 13 days. White scale bar is 200 µm.
  • Learn

    We learned from this Test that the concentration of G418 is not the only thing inhibiting the selection of transformants. We also discovered that the resistance gene may not work or the DNA may not enter the cells.

  • Design

    In Cycle 1, we tried to obtain transformants by changing the concentration of G418 but failed. They also found that the resistance gene may not have worked, or the DNA may not have entered the cell. Therefore, we decided to reduce the difficulty of transfection by changing the method to transfection of one type of DNA instead of co-transfection of pCAGGS N-Cre and pMC1 neo-polyA (both are linearized).

    This means that Parts BBa_K4419025 has been improved: its promoter has been changed from a CAG promoter to a CMV promoter and a neomycin/kanamycin resistance gene has been added to the gene circuit. BBa_K4828018 was added to the Parts Registry.

  • Build

    As stated in the Design, in order to use a single DNA transfection method, we considered that the Neo-resistant gene should be present in the plasmid backbone that incorporates the genetic circuit of the infection-detecting cell. Therefore, we used pCMV N-Cre, a product in the process of making pCAGGS N-Cre. pCMV N-Cre has pIRES2-EGFP as its backbone and has Neo^R, so only one type of DNA is needed for transformation (Fig.4) .

    Fig.4 How to create infection-detecting cells2 Linearized pCMV N-Cre is transfected by Electroporation. The gene circuit is then incorporated into the cell genome by random integration. The resulting transformants (infection-detecting cells) are selected by applying selection pressure with G418.
    Fig.4 How to create infection-detecting cells2 Linearized pCMV N-Cre is transfected by Electroporation. The gene circuit is then incorporated into the cell genome by random integration. The resulting transformants (infection-detecting cells) are selected by applying selection pressure with G418.
  • Ttest

    We electroporated Linearized pCMV N-Cre into Vero as described in Build and performed selection with G418 900 µg/mL as required in Cycle 1. (Experiments 230221-230306) However, no transformants were obtained (Fig.5).

    Fig.5 Photograph of Vero cells electroporated with pCMV N-Cre and normal Vero cells selected with G418 G418 concentration was 900 µg/mL, selection was performed for 13 days. White scale bar is 200 µm.
    Fig.5 Photograph of Vero cells electroporated with pCMV N-Cre and normal Vero cells selected with G418 G418 concentration was 900 µg/mL, selection was performed for 13 days. White scale bar is 200 µm.
  • Learn
    We realized that co-transfection was not the root of the problem with this Test. Since the fluorescence of this Test showed little green fluorescence, we could hypothesize that very little DNA was transformed into the Vero cells.
  • Design

    In Cycle 2, the plasmid backbone was changed to reduce the difficulty of transformation, but no transformants were obtained. However, we thought that Vero cells might contain little DNA, so we decided to review the conditions of Electroporation.

  • Build

    As described in Experiments 230412, 230427, Linearized pCMV N-Cre under various PULSE conditions were electroporated and selected with G418 900 µg/mL. (Experiments230412-230417, 230427-230430)

    We also stained some of the cells to which PULSE was added with trypan blue to see how many cells were killed by PULSE.

  • Ttest

    The selection did not result in transformants. In addition, a few cells were stained with trypan blue immediately after PULSE was added.

  • Learn

    We were able to confirm by this test that PULSE did not work at all against Vero cells. We thought that this was due to the conditions of the Electroporator or Electroporation.

  • Design

    In Cycle 3 we discovered that there was some problem with our Electroporation. Therefore, we planned to change our transformation method. First of all, we considered changing the conditions of electroporation. However, we soon realized that it was not realistic to search for the optimal PULSE because there were too many conditions to consider. Next, we considered trying Lipofection. However, we gave up because of the high cost of the reagents. So we decided to consult Dr. Suzuki, who has been helping us with SRIP production experiments.

  • Build

    After consulting with Dr. Suzuki, he recommended using PEI: polyethylenimine, which is inexpensive and often used for transfection, and gave us some PEI (Fig.6). (See Human Practices for details.) We immediately performed transfection using PEI. (Experiments 230901, 230905)

    Fig.6 iGEM TokyoTech members with Dr. Suzuki and Dr. Matsuda from National Institute of Infectious Diseases
    Fig.6 iGEM TokyoTech members with Dr. Suzuki and Dr. Matsuda from National Institute of Infectious Diseases
  • Ttest

    The high fluorescence intensity, which was not seen in Electroporation, was confirmed. However, the PEI-based method transformed cyclic pCMV N-Cre instead of linearized pCMV N-Cre (Fig.7).

    Fig.7  A: pCMV N-Cre plasmid map B: SRIP infection detecting cells Vero transfected with pCMV N-Cre by using  PEI: Polyethylenimine
    Fig.7 A: pCMV N-Cre plasmid map B: SRIP infection detecting cells Vero transfected with pCMV N-Cre by using PEI: Polyethylenimine
  • Learn

    PEI can successfully transform the cells, indirectly proving that there is a problem with the electroporation conditions as per Learn in Cycle 3. Although PEI involves introducing a circular plasmid, it is still necessary to aim for random integration into the cell genome by transforming linear DNA to isolate transformants, i.e., to establish cell lines.

As stated in the Description and Design, the CFNT: Cell Fluorescence Neutralization Test measures the amount of neutralizing antibodies in the subject's serum. The amount of neutralizing antibodies is quantified by the ratio of green to red fluorescence, making the infection-detecting cells one of the most important components of the CFNT. In addition, as shown in the Design and Proof of Concept, the cost of introducing CFNTs will be reduced if infection-detecting cells can be generated from mosquito C6/36 cells and cultured without an incubator. Therefore, we experimented by running a DBTL cycle to culture mosquito cells, C6/36 cells, without the maintenance of a 5% carbon dioxide concentration.

  • Design
    First, we planned an experiment to create a Growth Curve by seeding C6/36 cells in 96-well plates and counting the number of C6/36 cells using WST-8. However, the cells did not grow well due to bacterial contamination. Therefore, we decided to examine the cause of contamination first.
  • Build
    The medium used was placed in an empty dish and incubated at 37°C overnight to ensure that the medium used was not contaminated.
  • Ttest
    It was confirmed that the medium was contaminated.
  • Learn
    Penicillin was added to the next medium used.
  • Design
    We tried to start the experiment again with penicillin-containing medium as improved in Cycle 1, but again contamination was observed. We decided to further investigate the cause of the contamination.
  • Build
    We thought that the experimenter's poor technique was causing the contamination, so we changed the method of handling the cells from a 1 mL stripper to a dropper.
  • Ttest
    No contamination was observed when cells were seeded with the dropper.
  • Learn
    We learned that the manipulation at hand plays a major role in contamination and that the skill of the experimenter is essential for the success of the experiment.

CFNT: Cell Fluorescence Neutralization Test measures the amount of neutralizing antibodies in a subject's serum as described in Description and Design. As described in Description and Design, it measures the amount of neutralizing antibodies in the subject's serum. The amount of neutralizing antibodies is quantified by the ratio of green to red fluorescence. Infection-detecting cells that normally show green fluorescence become red fluorescent when infected with SRIP: Single-round Infectious Particle, which is similar to DENV: Dengue virus. In other words, whether or not SRIP is neutralized by antibodies in the serum is determined by the color of the fluorescence, and the ratio of green to red fluorescence intensity is used to determine the anti-DENV neutralizing antibody titer. Therefore, SRIP is one of the most important components of CFNT.

For the SRIP preparation, we replaced the nluc gene of pCMV YF-nluc-rep provided by Dr. Suzuki with the C-Cre gene to construct pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep (for details, see Design), starting with the construction of pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep (see design for details). We then ran multiple DBTL cycles to complete this construction.

  • Design

    As described in Experiments230206, we cut out the nluc gene using restriction enzymes and ligated the C-Cre gene as an insert. However, when we transformed the ligation product, no colonies grew. Since we were concerned about the low amount of vector during the experiment, we decided to extract more plasmids from E. coli because we thought it was necessary to prepare a larger amount of plasmids.

  • Build

    Since pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep is a low-copy plasmid, we added chloramphenicol to E. coli culture medium in the logarithmic growth phase. This resulted in a 3-fold increase in the amount of plasmid compared to normal (Fig.8).(Experiments230519)

    Fig.8 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep plasmid prepartaion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with pCMV YF-nluc-rep. Left: Plasmid extracted from E. coli cultured in LB medium without chloramphenicol. Right: plasmid extracted from E. coli cultured in LB medium with 25 µg/mL chloramphenicol. ×4, ×2, ×1, ×1/2, and ×1/4 indicate how much plasmid solution was added based on ×1. B: pCMV YF-nluc-rep plasmid map
    Fig.8 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep plasmid prepartaion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with pCMV YF-nluc-rep. Left: Plasmid extracted from E. coli cultured in LB medium without chloramphenicol. Right: plasmid extracted from E. coli cultured in LB medium with 25 µg/mL chloramphenicol. ×4, ×2, ×1, ×1/2, and ×1/4 indicate how much plasmid solution was added based on ×1. B: pCMV YF-nluc-rep plasmid map
  • Ttest

    A sufficient amount of plasmid was digested with SnaB I, the next step. However, there was still some residue, so another overnight restriction enzyme treatment was performed. However, there were still remnants (Fig. 9).(Experiments230607)

    Fig.9 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep SnaB I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-luc-rep from E.coli and pCMV YF-luc-rep digested with SnaB I. B: pCMV YF-luc-rep plasmid map.
    Fig.9 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep SnaB I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-luc-rep from E.coli and pCMV YF-luc-rep digested with SnaB I. B: pCMV YF-luc-rep plasmid map.
  • Learn

    From the electrophoresis results of Test, we assumed that there was some reason why the plasmid could not be digested by restriction enzymes.

  • Design

    We found that the plasmid used in Cycle 1 was not digestible by the restriction enzyme. In response to this, we consulted with our PI and considered the possibility that the prolonged incubation of E. coli may have altered the properties of the plasmid.

  • Build

    To achieve what we discussed in Design, we performed plasmid extraction by reducing the incubation time of mass culture of E. coli transformed with pCMV YF-nluc-rep to less than 12 hours.

  • Ttest

    The plasmid extracted with Build was treated with restriction enzyme with SnaB I, but the remainder of the cut was still visible (Fig. 10).(Experiments230719)

    Fig.10 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep (Short-Time Culture) SnaB I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-nluc-rep from E.coli and pCMV YF-luc-rep digested with SnaB I B: pCMV YF-luc-rep plasmid map
    Fig.10 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep (Short-Time Culture) SnaB I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-nluc-rep from E.coli and pCMV YF-luc-rep digested with SnaB I B: pCMV YF-luc-rep plasmid map
  • Learn

    It was found that prolonged incubation was not the direct cause of the inability to process with the limiting enzyme.

  • Design

    In Cycle 1, we found that the plasmid used could not be digested by the restriction enzyme. In response to this, we consulted with our advisor and thought that the restriction enzyme might not be working well because the plasmid was taking on a higher-order structure. Therefore, we decided to perform heat shock to resolve the higher‐order structure of the plasmid.

  • Build

    pCMV YF-nluc-rep (R: SnaB I) was incubated at 65°C for 5 min and cooled rapidly in an attempt to resolve the higher-order structure. Restriction enzyme treatment was later performed again with SnaB I.

  • Ttest
    Fig.11 Analysis by agarose gel electrophoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep (R: SnaB I, Heat-shocked) SnaB I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-nluc-rep (R: SnaB I) and pCMV YF-luc-rep (R: SnaB I, Heat-shocked) digested with SnaB I B: pCMV YF-luc-rep plasmid map
    Fig.11 Analysis by agarose gel electrophoresis about pCMV YF-nluc-rep (R: SnaB I, Heat-shocked) SnaB I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-nluc-rep (R: SnaB I) and pCMV YF-luc-rep (R: SnaB I, Heat-shocked) digested with SnaB I B: pCMV YF-luc-rep plasmid map
  • Learn

    Higher-order structures are not the direct cause of the breakage remnant.

  • Design

    Cycle 2-1 and 2-2 were not able to eliminate the remaining pieces. Therefore, we planned to purify only the restriction enzyme-digested portions and use them for downstream.

  • Build

    The completely broken DNA was purified and used in a later ligation reaction for transformation.(Experiments230822-230824)

  • Ttest

    Colonies grew, so small cultures and small preparations of plasmid were made for all colonies. The extracted plasmids were checked for per colony by restriction enzyme Xma I digestion, but there were none (Fig.12).(Experiments230825-230901)

    Fig.12 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep colonies Xma I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep from E.coli and them digested with Xma I (expressed as R) B: pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep plasmid map
    Fig.12 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep colonies Xma I digestion A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with extracted pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep from E.coli and them digested with Xma I (expressed as R) B: pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep plasmid map
  • Learn

    We had considered plasmid construction using restriction enzymes and ligase for Cycle 1-4, but considering the time remaining, we decided that we would be closer to completion if we tried a different approach.

  • Design

    Consider plasmid constructions without restriction enzymes and ligases.

  • Build

    Inverse PCR was used to amplify all but the nluc gene of pCMV YF-nluc-rep, and the C-Cre gene was incorporated by TaKaRa's InFusion to produce pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep, which was transformed into E.coli.(Experiments230906-230921)

  • Ttest

    Colonies were grown and colony PCR was performed. The colonies per colony were supposed to show a band at 383 b. However, all the bands that were seen appeared at 563 b or higher. However, the bands that were seen were all at 563 b or higher. Considering that the primers used in this colony PCR annealed to pCMV YF-nluc-rep and produced a DNA fragment of 599 b, it is likely that all the colonies that emerged this time had the original pCMV YF-nluc-rep vector (Fig. 13).(Experiments230922)

    Fig.13 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep colony PCR A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with colony PCR product B: pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep plasmid map
    Fig.13 Analysis by agarose gel electro phoresis about pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep colony PCR A: 0.6% agarose gel image, loaded with colony PCR product B: pCMV YF-C-Cre-rep plasmid map
  • Learn

    We were unable to complete the plasmid construction in InFusion because the PCR products were not purified by the method of cutting them out of the gel, which we believe resulted in contamination of the large source plasmid. Therefore, we believe that the method of gel extraction of the PCR product would allow us to successfully complete the plasmid construction in InFusion.

Reference