Human Practice
1. Introduction
Our journey begins with a compelling source of inspiration: iGEM LINKS China 2021, who astutely emphasized that "The core of Human Practices is to show that your project is good and responsible to the world, so the first thing iGEM team should do is to clarify their own values." Guided by this profound wisdom, our initial step upon identifying our central predicament was to undertake a thorough value-sensitive analysis. This was a crucial endeavor aimed at ensuring the righteousness of our project's trajectory while steadfastly preserving our core values as the cornerstones of our project's design.
Furthermore, our commitment to excellence led us to apply for and secure the Impact Grant, an achievement that encouraged us to delve even deeper into the essence of our project. Through extensive interactions with external stakeholders, we engaged in profound reflection, scrutinizing the compatibility of our project and research methodologies with the overarching goal of promoting global welfare and responsibility, enabled us to make Reflection & Conclusion. This journey of introspection ultimately culminated in a profound realization of the responsibility we bear in shaping the world for the better, prompting us to draw valuable insights and conclusions that we share with you today.
Make sure to read the Integrated human practice page to learn how we implemented the feedback of stakeholders in our project.
2. Background Investigation
After many engagements with professors outside and inside of our team, we also did a background investigation about our project to better understand and explain the urgency of the problem and the meaning of tackling this problem.
In United States, ethanol yields have risen from 8.3 L of ethanol per bushel of corn to more than 10.2 L per bushel, capital costs have decreased from $0.95 per liter to approximately $0.26 per liter. Improving fermentation temperature every 2℃ can reduce the energy consumption of distillation by 1%. The tolerance modify of the industry strains also can saving energy consumption. Operation at high temperatures and using thermotolerant yeast can significantly reduce the cooling costs and help preventing contamination. High-temperature cultivation will not only benefit a simultaneous saccharification and fermentation process, given that the current compromise between the optimal fermentation temperature (30-35℃) and saccharification temperature (50℃) 1, but also mitigate the cooling costs, avoid or minimize microbial contamination.
Take million tons of chemicals enterprise for example, according to the calculations, the cooling water and cooling power consumption will be reduced 15% and 10% respectively every year if the fermentation temperature is increased 5℃. Moreover, the optimal growth temperature of S. cerevisiae is also dismatch with the optimum enzymatic temperature (35-50℃) leading to the poor enzymatic efficiency. 2
There are typically three strategies are widely used, namely irrational, rational and semi-rational strategy. The irrational strategy follows an directed evolution approach, generating a large number of mutants and screening strains with the desired phenotype by high-throughput techniques. The rational strategy is built upon a fundamental understanding of cellular processes, aiming to confer stress tolerance to cell factories by directly modifying its genome. And semi-rational strategy, which is the preferred method for the majority of researchers, emphasizes the integration of partial understanding of cellular processes with evolutionary techniques, involving preparing mutants libraries more accurately. Here, we discuss the exploration of stress-tolerant parts and different strategies in constructing stress-tolerant S. cerevisiae cell factories. This background investigation gave us many resources to develop our project and made us have more deeply understand about the advance.
Irrational strategy
Certain important traits in production, such as high temperature and acid-alkaline tolerance, are often regulated by multiple genes. Obtaining specific target and elucidating the associated signaling pathways in detail are crucial steps in obtaining cell factories with corresponding stress tolerance capabilities, which can be resource-intensive. However, the irrational strategy involves the iterative process of random mutagenesis and directed selection to obtain cell factories with improved stress tolerance, meaning that this strategy can help reduce the complexity of the overall research.
Specifically, applying external pressure on cell factories through continuous cultivation, followed by further isolation and purification, is a common approach to directly obtain populations with desired traits. For example, continuous cultivation and passaging of S. cerevisiae under conditions such as high temperature and low pH, followed by detection and isolation of corresponding advantageous mutants, have been employed to obtain heat- and acid-tolerant strains, respectively. However, this method consumes a mount of efforts and resources, and it relies on the instability of endogenous cellular systems(such as denaturation of protein and formation of reactive oxygen species (ROS)) to induce mutations, making it sensitive to factors such as genome accessibility, thereby making it difficult to generate high-quality and homogeneous mutant libraries. Applying random mutated techniques directly targeting genome, which includes physical/chemical methods and biological methods, can rapidly generate a large mutant library for subsequent stress screening. In addition to traditional methods such as radiation and alkylating agents, atmospheric and room temperature plasma (ARTP) represents a novel physical and chemical mutagenesis method, which can generate libraries with a large number of random mutations without relying on toxic or hazardous reagents. For example, ARTP mutagenesis was used to obtain S. cerevisiae cell factories with low pH tolerance3. On the other hand, gene editing techniques represented by the CRISPR/Cas9 are the main biological mutagenesis methods, which offer easier control over mutation rates but come with higher costs. By combining the principles of homology-directed repair(HDR)4 or cDNA library preparation technology5, researchers have also obtained S. cerevisiae cell factories with tolerance to furfural, acetic acid and others.
Above discussed strategies are almost based on the principle of genetic mutation, however, chromosomal aberration, including changes in chromosome structure and chromosome number, is equally important for irrational strategies. Large-scale chromosomal structural variations rely on efficient protoplast fusion, which suffers from instability now. S. cerevisiae containing artificially synthesized chromosomes, with non-directional recombination sites (loxPsym) inserted on both sides of a large number of genes, serve as excellent materials for constructing mutant libraries through gene recombination. However, direct utilization of the Synthetic Chromosome Rearrangement and Modification by LoxP-mediated Evolution (SCRaMbLE) system may result in high lethality. To overcome this difficulty, two groups used wild-type S. cerevisiae chromosome in combination with an artificially synthesized chromosome to create a partial heterozygous diploid, which provides a repair template for lethal rearrangements and effectively reduced the rate of lethality, and conferred heat/caffeine and alkali tolerance to S. cerevisiae cell factories, respectively67. Despite these efforts, imprecise control of SCRaMbLE system over gene recombination still poses challenges in generating high-quality mutant libraries. However, when combined with the reporter of SCRaMbLEd cells using efficient selection (ReSCuES) system8, the positive rate of reprogrammed yeast can be improved, enabling the rapid screening and selection of strains tolerant to ethanol, acetic acid and heat. According to above works, to further expand the range and quantity of mutants, integrating SCRaMbLE-mediated gene recombination and CRISPR/Cas9-mediated gene mutation may be a great choice. Chromosome number variation has been shown to be of significant importance for the adaptation of biological systems to the environment. Researchers have found that changes in genome ploidy could enhance vanillin tolerance and ethanol fermentation capability in S. cerevisiae cell factories 9. This suggests that studying chromosome number variation through traditional chemical methods that prevent mitosis or physical methods that introducing synthetic genomes by transformation may provide new avenues for enhancing stress tolerance in cell factories.
The application of irrational strategies allows cell factories to autonomously and maximally explore the fitness landscape of stress resistance. However, the potential of this strategy can’t be fully harnessed due to the large size of the mutants and inability of screening throughput. Therefore, enhancing screening throughput and reducing screening costs are crucial scientific questions. Moreover, although irrational strategies currently contribute to some extent in improving stress tolerance of S. cerevisiae cell factories, explaining the origin of this tolerance is not a straightforward task. That is because of the insufficient understanding of the parts responsible for stress tolerance. Therefore, further exploration and characterization of these parts can partially address this issue.
Data Mining
Life systems constantly face stimuli in complex and ever-changing environments. It is not an exaggeration to say that biological processes have developed through interactions with environmental stimuli. Throughout billions of years of evolution, most life systems have developed the ability to cope with various adversities, which is functioning by stress-responsive parts that encompass gene expression products that directly or indirectly confer various defense mechanisms against environmental stress. Exploring stress-responsive elements not only helps us understand the origins of the complexity within life systems, but also provides fundamental parts for engineering stress-tolerant traits.
The complete sequencing and chemical synthesis of the S. cerevisiae genome have provided a solid foundation for exploring endogenous stress-responsive parts within the yeast genome. Researchers have constructed various mutant libraries, including deletion and overexpression mutants, resulting in abundant genome information. For instance, a mutant strain with tolerance to isobutanol was identified by screening a yeast deletion library, specifically targeting GLN310. Furthermore, extensive omics studies have revealed endogenous stress-related elements in S. cerevisiae. Two groups employed transcriptome analysis under high-temperature[11] and acetic acid12 stress conditions, respectively, and identified endogenous elements associated with heat and acid tolerance. Similarly, transcriptome data was utilized to construct a CRISPRa screening library and discovered the heat resistance-related gene OLE113.
In addition S. cerevisiae itself, another promising approach is to mine and characterize stress-responsive parts from the genomes of different species. Particularly, plants that can’t easily adapt environment through broad migration and microorganisms living in extreme environments, are worth special attention. Performing multi-omics analyses on organisms(such as plants) with multiple systems or growth stages can rapidly identify differentially expressed genes among various systems under stress conditions. C. Jia et al. have elucidated the crucial role of the phenylpropanoid biosynthesis pathway under salt stress by metabolomics and transcriptomics, providing insights into enhancing the salt tolerance of S. cerevisiae cell factories14. However, these methods may not be fully applicable to extreme microorganisms due to challenges associated with culturing them in the laboratory. A viable strategy is to perform metagenomic analysis directly from environmental samples. Kaushal et al. has discovered a highly active β-glucosidase, BglM, capable of maintaining high activity in high temperature, high glucose concentration and ethanol, from a hyperthermophilic aquatic habitat metagenomic data resource15. This enzyme has the potential to improve the overall performance of cell factories. However, this approach only reveals the most typical stress-responsive parts and does not provide a systematic understanding of extreme microorganisms’ metabolic network patterns. Therefore, there is still considerable room for improvement in methods for genome resource mining specifically targeting extreme microorganisms.
The exploration of stress-responsive parts requires both the development of new technologies to improve efficiency and the meticulous annotation and mining of existing information by numerous research teams. Only with a sufficient foundation of information on stress-responsive elements can rational design strategies be fully applied to construct cell factories with various stress-tolerant capabilities.
Rational/semi-rational
It is true that irrational strategies rely on the preparation of mutant libraries and the development of high-throughput screening techniques. However, there are still challenges associated with the efficiency and quality of mutant library preparation, as well as the high cost and limited applicability of high-throughput screening, which prevent these strategies from being widely used in everyday laboratory settings. Actually, from the understanding of the biological processes of tolerance, researchers often employ rational design approaches to modify the metabolism and regulatory networks of S. cerevisiae or construct synthetic gene circuits using stress-responsive parts from different sources to enhance the stress tolerance of S. cerevisiae cell factories.
To address stress from factors such as acidity, high osmolarity, and toxic compounds that present in fermentation broth, researchers often employ various efficient transport proteins to directly export the stressors out of the cell. For example, overexpress the dicarboxylic acid transporter SpMae1 and its homolog AcDct gene16, or a human fatty alcohol transporter protein FATP117, can improve the tolerance of S. cerevisiae cell factories to dicarboxylic acids and fatty alcohols, respectively. However, factors beneficial to cell factory production, such as the K(+)/H(+) transmembrane concentration gradient, can be harnessed by transporting them into the cell. For example, overexpress the potassium ion importer gene TRK1 enhances the tolerance of S. cerevisiae cell factories to fatty alcohols. Regarding external stressors like high temperature, where the number of directly associated targets is limited, it is often more advantageous to improve the overall performance of the cell factory or enhance the strength of certain stress response systems within the cell factory. For example, constructing an artificial protein quality control system to improve protein stability can enhance the heat resistance of S. cerevisiae cell factories.
In addition, several stress response systems developed in other cell factories are worth expanding for application in S. cerevisiae. For example, the IMHeRE system18 has been constructed in E. coli, utilizing a riboswitch to respond to different temperatures and producing different heat shock proteins (HSPs) to cope with high-temperature stress. On the other hand, the genetic pH shooting (GPS) system19, uses acid/alkali-inducible promoters for intelligent pH regulation, thereby improving the fitness of the cell factory in acidic or alkaline environments. Combining with quorum sensing and suicide systems, these basic designs can achieve intelligent control of cell density and enhance production performance. And by leveraging riboswitches and various stress-responsive parts, it is possible to construct automated regulatory circuits for different and sole stressors. Designs incorporating promoters that respond to different stimuli can enable intelligent responses to multiple stressors, such as implementing AND gates or OR gates, and can also be used to explore the interplay between various stress factors.
Compared to non-rational strategies, employing rational strategy in the construction of stress-tolerant yeast cell factories offers enhanced design precision, significantly reduces screening challenges, and allows for more refined target selection. Moreover, this approach enables researchers to conduct in-depth analyses of selected genes, encompassing both phenotypic and molecular mechanisms, leading to comprehensive characterizations. However, the success of rational design relies on the prior identification of stress-responsive parts and the availability of tools for precise genomic manipulation. The exploration of stress-responsive parts often generates substantial data, making it challenging to achieve fully characterization of all parts within the S. cerevisiae cell factories.
Therefore, based on a partial understanding of biological systems, integrating both non-rational and rational strategies, a new approach has emerged for constructing stress-tolerant yeast cell factories by narrowing the focus and generating locally dense mutant libraries. This approach combines high-throughput screening and limited directed engineering and is known as a semi-rational strategy. For instance, the semi-rational strategy involves the use of error-prone PCR to construct mutant libraries targeting the global transcription factor SPT15, which participates in numerous regulatory processes in S. cerevisiae, leading to the rapid generation of highly ethanol-tolerant strains20. Additionally, constructing random libraries using stress-responsive parts and different strength promoters and terminators from various species enables the screening of cell factories with improved stress tolerance and production capacity21. Furthermore, in vivo continuous evolution techniques can facilitate autonomous strain iteration, greatly enhancing the efficiency of laboratory-based evolutionary simulations. Crook, N et al.22 have employed retrotransposon-based in vivo continuous evolution (ICE) systems to enhance 1-butanol tolerance in S. cerevisiae, demonstrating the potential of these methods for broader applications. These approaches warrant further development to enhance their universality and applicability.
After decades of development, the construction of stress-tolerant S. cerevisiae cell factories has yielded significant achievements. The flexible application of non-rational, rational, and semi-rational strategies has enabled researchers to transform S. cerevisiae cell factories in multiple dimensions to enhance stress tolerance. However, improving stress tolerance often comes at the cost of decreased production performance, and the desired outcomes are not always achieved. This is because, on one hand, the generation of stress tolerance features and the expression levels of metabolites required for production may exhibit antagonistic effects, on the other hand, quantifying the impact of stress-related elements on the metabolic network itself is challenging. Therefore, achieving a balance between production performance and stress tolerance is a crucial consideration when constructing S. cerevisiae cell factories that can be effectively used for production.
In conclusion, previous research has provided numerous methods and tools for the construction of S. cerevisiae cell factories. We try to imitate the rational design method to develop our project due to our inspiration source.
During the investigation, we noticed in one paper pointed out that rational design by overexpressing multiple genes to improve cell tolerance and robustness is challenging.
3. Stakeholders Analysis
Through brainstorming we analyzed the stakeholders of our project involves identifying individuals, groups that are directly or indirectly affected by or have an interest in the outcomes and activities of our biomanufacturing project focused on improving Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell factories' heat resistance. Here are our key stakeholders:
Understanding these stakeholders and their interests can help us navigate the project effectively, communicate its importance, and foster collaborations where necessary. It's important to engage with and consider the needs and concerns of these stakeholders throughout our research and development process.
4. Value-sensitive analysis
In the spirit of iGEM, our journey commenced with a deliberate and meticulous approach. Upon confirming the paramount nature of our central predicament, our foremost endeavor was to embark on a comprehensive voyage of value-sensitive analysis. Our primary objective in this endeavor was to ensure that the trajectory of our efforts remained steadfast in alignment with our fundamental principles. As we embarked on this journey, we held fast to the bedrock of our initial values, guiding every facet of our project design.
In pursuit of this endeavor, we undertook a series of distinct surveys and analyses that encompassed a multifaceted spectrum. These analytical pursuits were meticulously structured to delve into the intricate domains of the economy, environment, social considerations, ethical implications, regulatory frameworks, scientific foundations, safety protocols, and the intricate realm of data collection. The forthcoming discourse will delineate the specifics of each of these analyses, providing a comprehensive view of our rigorous investigative process.
Economic
value:By improving the heat resistance of Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell factories, our project aims to reduce one of the significant production costs in bioethanol manufacturing - the need for artificial cooling. This cost reduction directly translates into economic value by making the entire bioethanol production process more cost-effective. When production costs decrease, profit margins can increase, potentially leading to higher overall profitability.
norms:Seeking cost reduction and increased profitability, which are common goals in business and industry, within the business and industrial sectors, the pursuit of cost reduction and increased profitability is a widely accepted and encouraged norm. It aligns with the fundamental objective of maximizing the efficiency of operations and investments. Reducing production costs is a strategic move that businesses employ to remain competitive and improve their financial performance.
Design requirement:Cost-saving strategies: This involves identifying and implementing strategies that minimize expenses at various stages of bioethanol production. These strategies could include resource-efficient raw material usage, energy-saving technologies, and streamlined processes to reduce waste.
Efficent heat resistance mechanisms: The core of our project's design should revolve around enhancing the heat resistance of Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell factories. This could include genetic modifications or other techniques to ensure that yeast cells can thrive in higher-temperature environments without the need for extensive cooling.
Optimization of fermentation process: Efficient fermentation is crucial for maximizing economic value. Our design should aim to optimize the fermentation process by closely monitoring variables such as temperature, pH, and nutrient availability. This optimization ensures that bioethanol production is not only cost-effective but also consistently high in quality.
Environment
value:By reducing the need for artificial cooling in the fermentation process, the project aligns with sustainability goals. One of the significant environmental benefits of our project is its potential to reduce the energy consumption associated with bioethanol production. Traditional cooling methods often require significant energy inputs, which can lead to a higher carbon footprint. By enhancing the heat resistance of Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell factories and eliminating or reducing the need for artificial cooling, our project contributes to sustainability efforts. This is because lower energy consumption means a reduced demand for fossil fuels, which can ultimately lead to lower greenhouse gas emissions.
norms:Encouraging the reduction of energy consumption and environmental impact in industrial processes. Within the broader context of industry and environmental norms, there is a growing consensus on the importance of reducing energy consumption and mitigating environmental impact. Governments, regulatory bodies, and consumers increasingly prioritize sustainable and eco-friendly practices. This aligns with the expectation that industries should actively seek ways to reduce their energy usage and environmental footprint as part of their corporate social responsibility.
Design requirement:Environmental Impact Minimization: Consider the broader environmental impact of our project. Assess how the modifications made to Saccharomyces cerevisiae cell factories impact the ecosystem and surroundings. Ensure that the genetic modifications do not pose unintended environmental risks.
Carbon Footprint Assessment: Conduct a comprehensive assessment of the project's carbon footprint. This should include an analysis of the emissions saved by reducing artificial cooling, as well as any emissions associated with the genetic modifications. Such an assessment helps quantify our project's environmental benefits and adherence to sustainability goals.
Social
value:Our project contributes to social values related to environmental conservation and sustainability. Bioethanol production is seen as a greener and more sustainable approach compared to traditional chemical manufacturing processes. It offers the potential to reduce the environmental impact and reliance on fossil fuels, addressing key concerns shared by society at large.
norms:In contemporary society, there is a growing consensus on the importance of sustainability and reducing the carbon footprint. This norm encourages the adoption of renewable energy sources, such as bioethanol, as a way to mitigate climate change and environmental degradation. Sustainable practices and technologies that align with these norms are often celebrated and supported.
Design requirement:Community Engagement: Engage with local communities and stakeholders to ensure they are informed about the project's goals, potential benefits, and any associated risks. Actively seek feedback and address concerns to build trust and foster a sense of ownership among the community.
Transparency: Maintain transparency throughout the project by providing accessible and clear information about our research, genetic modifications, and their potential implications. Transparency helps to demystify biotechnology and genetics and fosters understanding among the public.
Communication Strategy: Develop a robust communication strategy to convey the societal benefits of our project. Emphasize its role in reducing greenhouse gas emissions, promoting renewable energy, and contributing to a more sustainable future. Address any misconceptions or concerns proactively.
Risk Assessment: Assess and communicate potential risks associated with genetic modifications. Discuss safety measures, containment protocols, and ethical considerations to demonstrate responsible research practices.
Ethical
value:Ethical value in our project underscores the fundamental importance of conducting research in a manner that upholds principles of responsibility, safety, and respect for ethical guidelines. Ethical research practices are not only morally imperative but also ensure the integrity and credibility of our work.
norms:Transparency: Openly sharing information about the nature of our research, its objectives, and potential implications to foster understanding and trust among stakeholders.
TInformed Consent : When involving stakeholders, ensuring that individuals are fully informed about the project and voluntarily agree to participate, especially if their participation could have implications for them or their community.
Responsible Use of Genetic Modification Techniques: Using genetic modification techniques with the utmost responsibility, which includes following best practices, safety protocols, and ensuring that modifications are scientifically sound and ethically justified
Design requirement:Safety Protocols: Develop and implement stringent safety protocols when working with genetically modified yeast.
Ethical Review Processes: Subject our project to rigorous ethical review processes, especially if it involves potentially sensitive genetic modifications.
Adherence to Ethical Guidelines: Strictly adhere to established ethical guidelines specific to genetic modification, biomanufacturing, and biotechnology research.
Regulatory
value:Compliance with national and international regulations governing genetic modification and biomanufacturing is crucial: Regulatory value in our project emphasizes the critical importance of adhering to established legal and regulatory frameworks that govern genetic modification and biomanufacturing. Compliance ensures not only the legality of our research but also its ethical and safe conduct.
norms:Safety: Ensuring our research activities are conducted in a manner that prioritizes safety for researchers, the public, and the environment. This includes containment protocols, emergency response plans, and hazard assessments.
Legal alignment: Aligning research practices with national and international legal requirements to ensure that the research is conducted within the boundaries set by regulatory authorities.
Design requirement:Permit acquisition: Identify and secure all necessary permits and approvals from relevant regulatory bodies before commencing your research.
Adherence to regulatory guidelines: Ensure strict adherence to regulatory guidelines governing genetic modification and biomanufacturing processes. This includes complying with safety standards, containment protocols, and ethical guidelines.
Documentation of compliance: Maintain thorough and well-organized documentation to demonstrate compliance with all relevant regulations. Documenting every aspect of our research process, from genetic modifications to safety protocols, is essential for transparency and accountability
Scientific
value:The scientific value of our project underscores the fundamental importance of conducting research that adheres to established scientific norms. These norms encompass rigorous methodologies, thorough data collection, and the validation of research findings through peer-reviewed processes.
norms:Rigorous testing: Employing meticulous and well-structured experimental design and testing methodologies to ensure that research outcomes are based on sound scientific principles.
Data collection: Thoroughly collecting, recording, and analyzing data in a systematic and unbiased manner to provide a comprehensive foundation for research conclusions.
Peer review: Subjecting research to the scrutiny of independent experts in the field through a peer-review process. This validation mechanism helps ensure the accuracy and robustness of research findings.
Design requirement:Rigorous methodologies: Implementing rigorous scientific methods that include clear protocols for genetic modification, experimentation, and data collection. These methodologies should be designed to minimize bias and confounding variables.
Clear documentation: Maintaining transparent and well-organized documentation throughout your research. This documentation should detail every aspect of your project, from experimental setups and protocols to data collection and analysis.
Peer review process: Committing to subject our research to peer review by independent experts in the field, and communicate with them.
Safety
value:tSafety value within our project emphasizes the utmost importance of ensuring the safety of all individuals involved in our research, as well as the environment. This value underscores the need for proactive measures to prevent accidental exposure to genetically modified yeast and contamination of the surrounding environment.
norms:Researcher safety: Prioritizing the safety of researchers by minimizing risks associated with genetic modification, laboratory work, and the handling of genetically modified yeast.
Public safety: Ensuring that research activities do not pose risks to the broader community or public health.
Environmental protection: Implementing measures to safeguard the environment from accidental release or contamination of genetically modified yeast.
Design requirement:Safety protocols: Clearly defining safety protocols for all stages of research, from genetic modification to experimentation. These protocols should cover safe laboratory practices, personal protective equipment (PPE) requirements, and methods for minimizing exposure risks.
Containment measures: Establishing containment measures to prevent the escape or accidental release of modified organisms. This might include physical containment, such as secure laboratory facilities, and biological containment through engineered safeguards.
Emergency response plans: Developing comprehensive emergency response plans to address unforeseen incidents, accidents, or breaches in containment. These plans should outline steps for containment, decontamination, and communication in case of emergencies.
5. Reflection & Conclusion(potential and challenges)
Through extensive interactions with external stakeholders, we engaged in profound reflection, scrutinizing the compatibility of our project and research methodologies with the overarching goal of promoting global welfare and responsibility, enabled us to make Reflection & Conclusion.
Industry
Potential:1. Reduced production costs and increased efficiency through heat-resistant Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains can lead to competitive advantages for bioethanol producers.
2. Aligns with industry trends toward sustainability, making our project appealing to environmentally conscious consumers and investors.
challenges:1. Implementing genetic modifications can be costly and require significant investments in research and development.
2. Ensuring that genetically modified strains meet regulatory and safety standards can be time-consuming and expensive.
Academic
Potential:1. Advances understanding of genetic modification's role in biomanufacturing, contributing to academic knowledge in biotechnology and genetic engineering.
2. Provides a basis for future research on polyamine applications in stress resistance and genetic modification techniques.
challenges:1. Peer-reviewed research involving genetic modification may face ethical scrutiny and require strict adherence to ethical guidelines.
2. Ensuring transparency in research methods and reporting is crucial for maintaining academic integrity.
Local Communities
Potential:1. Supports local sustainability goals by reducing energy consumption and potentially improving the environmental quality of nearby areas.
2. Creates opportunities for local employment and partnerships with biomanufacturing facilities.
challenges:1. Establishing effective communication channels with communities to build trust and address potential fears or misconceptions.
Government
Potential:1. Aligns with government initiatives for renewable energy and reducing greenhouse gas emissions, making it easier to secure government support and grants.
2. Demonstrates the country's commitment to sustainable and innovative biomanufacturing practices on the global stage.
challenges:1. Navigating complex regulatory processes and obtaining necessary permits for genetic modification and biomanufacturing.
2. Ensuring compliance with evolving national and international regulations related to biotechnology.
Public Organizations
Potential:1. Serves as a model for public organizations focused on sustainability and renewable energy, showcasing practical applications of genetic modification.
2. Offers opportunities for collaboration with public organizations to promote environmentally friendly biomanufacturing practices.
challenges:1. Overcoming public skepticism or resistance to genetic modification through educational initiatives and awareness campaigns.
2. Garnering public support for projects that involve genetic modification in biomanufacturing.
6. Reference
- Xu, K., Lv, B., Huo, Y.-X., & Li, C. (2018). Toward the lowest energy consumption and emission in biofuel production: combination of ideal reactors and robust hosts. Current Opinion in Biotechnology, 50, 19-24. doi:10.1016/j.copbio.2017.08.011
- Liu, Y., Zhang, G., Sun, H., Sun, X., Jiang, N., Rasool, A., … Li, C. (2014). Enhanced pathway efficiency of Saccharomyces cerevisiae by introducing thermo-tolerant devices. Bioresource Technology, 170, 38–44. doi:10.1016/j.biortech.2014.07.063
- Alper, H., Moxley, J., Nevoigt, E., Fink, G. R., & Stephanopoulos, G. (2006). Engineering yeast transcription machinery for improved ethanol tolerance and production. Science, 314(5805), 1565-1568. doi:10.1126/science.1131969
- Bao, Z., HamediRad, M., Xue, P., Xiao, H., Tasan, I., Chao, R., . . . Zhao, H. (2018). Genome-scale engineering of Saccharomyces cerevisiae with single-nucleotide precision. Nat Biotechnol, 36(6), 505-508. doi:10.1038/nbt.4132
- Crook, N., Abatemarco, J., Sun, J., Wagner, J. M., Schmitz, A., & Alper, H. S. (2016). In vivo continuous evolution of genes and pathways in yeast. Nat Commun, 7, 13051. doi:10.1038/ncomms13051
- Darbani, B., Stovicek, V., van der Hoek, S. A., & Borodina, I. (2019). Engineering energetically efficient transport of dicarboxylic acids in yeast Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A, 116(39), 19415-19420. doi:10.1073/pnas.1900287116
- Hu, Y., Zhu, Z., Nielsen, J., & Siewers, V. (2018). Heterologous transporter expression for improved fatty alcohol secretion in yeast. Metab Eng, 45, 51-58. doi:10.1016/j.ymben.2017.11.008
- Jia, C., Guo, B., Wang, B., Li, X., Yang, T., Li, N., . . . Yu, Q. (2022). Integrated metabolomic and transcriptomic analysis reveals the role of phenylpropanoid biosynthesis pathway in tomato roots during salt stress. Front Plant Sci, 13, 1023696. doi:10.3389/fpls.2022.1023696
- Jia, H., Sun, X., Sun, H., Li, C., Wang, Y., Feng, X., & Li, C. (2016). Intelligent Microbial Heat-Regulating Engine (IMHeRE) for Improved Thermo-Robustness and Efficiency of Bioconversion. ACS Synth Biol, 5(4), 312-320. doi:10.1021/acssynbio.5b00158
- Kaushal, G., Rai, A. K., & Singh, S. P. (2021). A novel beta-glucosidase from a hot-spring metagenome shows elevated thermal stability and tolerance to glucose and ethanol. Enzyme Microb Technol, 145, 109764. doi:10.1016/j.enzmictec.2021.109764
- Kuroda, K., Hammer, S. K., Watanabe, Y., Montano Lopez, J., Fink, G. R., Stephanopoulos, G., . . . Avalos, J. L. (2019). Critical Roles of the Pentose Phosphate Pathway and GLN3 in Isobutanol-Specific Tolerance in Yeast. Cell Syst, 9(6), 534-547 e535. doi:10.1016/j.cels.2019.10.006
- Lee, Y., Nasution, O., Choi, E., Choi, I. G., Kim, W., & Choi, W. (2015). Transcriptome analysis of acetic-acid-treated yeast cells identifies a large set of genes whose overexpression or deletion enhances acetic acid tolerance. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 99(15), 6391-6403. doi:10.1007/s00253-015-6706-y
- Li, C., Gao, X., Peng, X., Li, J., Bai, W., Zhong, J., . . . Li, C. (2020). Intelligent microbial cell factory with genetic pH shooting (GPS) for cell self-responsive base/acid regulation. Microb Cell Fact, 19(1), 202. doi:10.1186/s12934-020-01457-3
- Li, P., Fu, X., Zhang, L., & Li, S. (2019). CRISPR/Cas-based screening of a gene activation library in Saccharomyces cerevisiae identifies a crucial role of OLE1 in thermotolerance. Microb Biotechnol, 12(6), 1154-1163. doi:10.1111/1751-7915.13333
- Luo, Z., Wang, L., Wang, Y., Zhang, W., Guo, Y., Shen, Y., . . . Dai, J. (2018). Identifying and characterizing SCRaMbLEd synthetic yeast using ReSCuES. Nat Commun, 9(1), 1930. doi:10.1038/s41467-017-00806-y
- Ma, L., Li, Y., Chen, X., Ding, M., Wu, Y., & Yuan, Y. J. (2019). SCRaMbLE generates evolved yeasts with increased alkali tolerance. Microb Cell Fact, 18(1), 52. doi:10.1186/s12934-019-1102-4
- Qin, L., Dong, S., Yu, J., Ning, X., Xu, K., Zhang, S. J., . . . Li, C. (2020). Stress-driven dynamic regulation of multiple tolerance genes improves robustness and productive capacity of Saccharomyces cerevisiae in industrial lignocellulose fermentation. Metab Eng, 61, 160-170. doi:10.1016/j.ymben.2020.06.003
- Shen, M. J., Wu, Y., Yang, K., Li, Y., Xu, H., Zhang, H., . . . Boeke, J. D. (2018). Heterozygous diploid and interspecies SCRaMbLEing. Nat Commun, 9(1), 1934. doi:10.1038/s41467-018-04157-0
- Si, T., Chao, R., Min, Y., Wu, Y., Ren, W., & Zhao, H. (2017). Automated multiplex genome-scale engineering in yeast. Nat Commun, 8, 15187. doi:10.1038/ncomms15187
- Tian, T., Wu, D., Ng, C. T., Yang, H., Sun, J., Liu, J., & Lu, J. (2020). A multiple-step strategy for screening Saccharomyces cerevisiae strains with improved acid tolerance and aroma profiles. Appl Microbiol Biotechnol, 104(7), 3097-3107. doi:10.1007/s00253-020-10451-z
- Xu, K., Qin, L., Bai, W., Wang, X., Li, F., Ren, S., . . . Li, C. (2020). Multilevel Defense System (MDS) Relieves Multiple Stresses for Economically Boosting Ethanol Production of Industrial Saccharomyces cerevisiae. ACS Energy Letters, 5(2), 572-582. doi:10.1021/acsenergylett.9b02681
- Zheng, D. Q., Jin, X. N., Zhang, K., Fang, Y. H., & Wu, X. C. (2017). Novel strategy to improve vanillin tolerance and ethanol fermentation performances of Saccharomycere cerevisiae strains. Bioresour Technol, 231, 53-58. doi:10.1016/j.biortech.2017.01.040