Removing the "invisible" barriers to science education for the visually impaired, Creating and inclusive world together.
Inclusivity Project Overview
Welcome to our wiki page! We are BJEA-China, a group of dedicated and
passionate students. The Inclusivity Award was established in 2020 with the
goal of breaking down barriers for underrepresented groups in the field of
science. This year, BJEA-China has chosen to focus on the visually impaired
community.
One of our team members has firsthand experience working with the visually
impaired community doing volunteer work, and she has brought to our
attention: the misconception that most visually impaired individuals face
in China, which is that they are only suited to careers as massage
therapists.
In fact, with the latest advancements in technology, adequately trained
visually impaired individuals can handle various tasks, especially with the
assistance of screen-reading software. Many visually impaired individuals
are now pursuing rewarding careers in software development, translation,
editing, piano teaching, and more.
We were excited to learn that the top-tier international journal "Cell" has
published a paper on a groundbreaking scientific achievement: Ae CD
research team led by Professor Daniel Yoshor from Baylor College of
Medicine in the United States has successfully used dynamic stimulation of
visual cortex to produce vision of forms in blind humans. Although this
technology is not yet perfect and practical, it offers hope for the
visually impaired. We believe that the dream of visually impaired
individuals to see the world is within reach.
We conducted a comprehensive study on public awareness of visual impaired individuals by administering a questionnaire to 532 participants from all across China. To gain deeper insights, we also conducted interviews with more than 20 visually impaired youths.
Our efforts in assisting the visually impaired community have not only gained recognition within the blind community but have also served as an inspiration to the younger generation. Furthermore, they have had a positive impact at multiple levels, spanning from our school and local community to the city and even on a broader scale.
In our school, our activities have had an impact on both students and educators. We organized an event called “A Dark Hour for the Blind”, involving participants from various grade levels. Additionally, we created display boards to introduce blind scientists to students, raising their awareness of and respect for the visually impaired community.
Firstly, we designed Braille picture books and composed a song to convey biological knowledge. We set up an official account dedicated to our activities and celebrated blind scientists to expand our influence. Furthermore, we created a wiki compatible with screen reading systems. And we have developed "Glimmer Lab," an Audio-accessible interactive game designed to simulate biological scientific experiments, enabling visually impaired students to experience laboratory settings and engage in scientific exploration.
Our innovations reached far and wide, with a wide media coverage in more than 10 influential media outlets, including China Daily, People's Daily, China Radio International, China Culture and NetEase, Taiwan News, Jimu News, AsiaNet, China Culture, News Reader, along with some related website such as China Music Education Network and China Vision, a UK charity organization.
Through these media coverage, the impact of our project has not only been spread within China but has also reached a global audience, highlighting the importance of promoting inclusivity and accessibility.
Promoting inclusivity itself is a big challenge. Through thoughtful consideration, we are increasingly aware of the urgency of helping visually impaired individuals overcome the "invisible" barriers in science education and expanding their access to this field. This is a crucial step in creating a more harmonious and inclusive society. Only by doing so can we work together to create a more harmonious world.
Current Situation
Before commencing our inclusivity project, it was essential to thoroughly
understand the current challenges we face. Our insights have been shaped
through meaningful interactions with the visually impaired community, and
we are also deeply concerned about the growing prevalence of myopia among
the youth.
First and foremost, a significant societal challenge lies in the pervasive
lack of awareness regarding the substantial difficulties faced by visually
impaired individuals. According to a 2019 report by the World Health
Organization (WHO), At present at least 2.2 billion people around the world
have a vision impairment, of whom at least 1 billion have a vision
impairment that could have been prevented or is yet to be addressed. [1].
Despite these staggering numbers, this demographic encounters formidable
barriers in areas such as education, career opportunities, and social
integration. They contend with higher unemployment rates and limited access
to quality education, perpetuating inequality. Addressing this disparity is
paramount to ensuring equal opportunities and resources for all,
irrespective of visual impairments.
Additionally, the global surge in myopia, including among young people,
presents another pressing cause for concern. As per the National Health
Commission's data, the prevalence of myopia among Chinese children and
teenagers in 2020 stood at a staggering 52.7 percent [2]. This marked a 2.5
percentage point increase from 2019 while remaining 0.9 percentage points
lower than the 2018 figures [3]. This concerning trend continues to
exacerbate. Therefore, it is imperative to not only address the challenges
faced by the visually impaired but also to confront the growing myopia
problem to safeguard the health and development of youth.
Background
To gain a comprehensive understanding of the requirements, we conducted
thorough background research using various methods. We recognized the
challenges faced by visually impaired individuals in education and careers.
To better understand their needs and struggles, we visited China Braille
Library in Beijing, China's only such specialist facility. During this
visit, we engaged in face-to-face discussions and interviews with visually
impaired children. These candid dialogues not only enriched our
understanding of their genuine perspectives and difficulties but also
served as a driving force for our project. Furthermore, our efforts
garnered the attention of multiple media outlets, thereby amplifying the
awareness surrounding the challenges confronted by the visually impaired
within our society.
Meanwhile, we designed a questionnaire survey to assess the public's
awareness concerning visually impaired individuals and collect suggestions
from respondents. This survey allowed our team to develop more targeted
solutions to promote societal inclusivity and safeguarding the well-being
and growth of our youth.
Questionnaire
A survey on the inclusion of visually impaired people in scientific research
First and foremost, 523 people participated in the questionnaire. It gives us more specific details, and we can analyze the meaning and circumstances behind the results. Also, the gender of the questionnaire participants is almost equal, which we can safely point out that the result has avoided the error of gender difference.
question 1: Your gender
question 2: Your age
By considering the age of people, we can better understand the response from a diverse group, which is more accurate. The distribution is in the range of 31-40; the people in this group attained one-third of the questionnaire, and it has suitable working experience and productivity, which means these people are most likely to be involved in the working area of scientific research.
question 3: Your education background
Our population's educational background is distributed across various levels, which is very suitable for our research.
question 4: Are you engaged in scientific research?
According to data, ore than half of the participants do not have a job or major that is related to scientific research, so only 46% of people have a certain level of accurate information and the truth. However, we can also obtain information from the other group; they can provide the idea and concept that has the highest and truest expression without any intervention by staying away from a certain area.
question 5: People with visual impairment should have equal opportunities to participate in scientific research as people without visual impairment
One-third of participants chose partial agreement, and about 40 percent of participants selected disagree and neutrality. In fact, people with visual impairment are supposed to have an equal opportunity to attach the scientific research area. It is true that visual disability has a negative impact, but it still highly depends on the scientific research ability. Thus, everyone is equally given the opportunity to do it.
question 6: Do you think that providing more scientific research tools and technologies adapted to the needs of people with visual impairment will help advance their development in the field?
Fifty percent of people agree with the statement; also, more people come up to neutrality from disagreement, which shows hesitation in their response, and the reason might be they are not familiar with the operation of the job of scientific research that we already mentioned above, more than help participants are unrelated to this area.
question 7: What do you think are the main challenges that people with visual impairment face in the field of scientific research? [Multiple choice]
There are multiple challenges for people with visual impairment, and most responses to this question think that the main challenge is the prejudice and discrimination against them. This response has a similarity, and also demonstrates question 5, that half of the participants think the people with visual disability did not have an equal chance with the able-body person. Moreover, participants also think there is a lack of tools and technology to help them with scientific work.
question 8: What do you think are the key measures to improve opportunities for people with visual impairment to participate in research? [Multiple choice]
The response has an equal distribution that provides the specific tools and equipment as assistance, offers certain materials to support them taking part in the work, and promotes the scientific area access and connectivity. We believe these suggestions are beneficial to people with visual impairment.
question 9: Do you consider providing special training and support when hiring researchers with visual impairment?
About 60 percent of participants would like to offer assistance to people with sight disability when they are inviting applications for jobs, which can bring a lot of aid to them. In this way, they can increase their efficiency.
question 10: Do you know about the important achievements of visual impairment researchers in your field?
More than 50 percent of participants know that accomplishments in the area are from the people who are disabled with sight. It demonstrates that these people are not as good as normal people, even if they are better. Therefore, we should stop discriminating against them and provide some assistance in order to achieve the target with better cooperation.
question 11: Do you think that society's prejudice against people with visual impairments affects their progress in their field?
Most people think that discrimination against people who have a visual impairment can harm their development. It is worth acknowledging that it will cause some negative influences on them, such as they might get less chance to perform, less work to do, and fewer resources compared to the normal person.
question 12: Do you know the national support policy for the visually impaired?
Almost 80 percent of participants were aware of the policy for helping people with visual impairment, but some of them had not heard about it. For the sake of assisting these special people and having better development together, the policy should be more popular to keep their rights well-balanced.
conclusion
Based on the above response and information with analysis, we can safely draw that people with visual impairments are easily discriminant, and the resources provided are not equal to them as able-body persons. However, most participants point out that these people have good achievements in certain areas, and they might perform better if they are treated as normal people and offered some specific assistance. Meanwhile, each country should also publish some policy and system to help them, show that it is committed to the equalization of each person, and also boost the future development of the country. Based on these findings, we decided to address discrimination by raising awareness and understanding of the visually impaired and designing products to help them learn about science
Interview with Visually Impaired Youth
We have frequently visited visually impaired youngsters, engaging with them
in face-to-face interactions to obtain a deeper understanding of their
current educational environment in China. These conversations have yielded
invaluable insight into their perspectives, real-world challenges and
demands in science education.
Through these interactions, we have discovered that their strong desire to
engage with science and to have educational opportunities that are on par
with their sighted peers. Unfortunately, traditional teaching approaches
heavily reliant on visual components pose significant disadvantages for
visually impaired students.
In response to these challenges, we have taken proactive measures such as
innovative teaching methodologies. Our goal is to provide enhanced
educational support tailored to the unique needs of visually impaired
students.
Moreover, throughout our visits to the China Braille Library, we've
organized several science storytelling sessions for visually impaired
children, allowing us to impart essential scientific knowledge, thereby
enhancing their educational experience. It's been truly gratifying to
witness their eagerness to hear captivating science stories.
Our efforts have drawn the interest and recognition of China Daily, the
leading English-language media group in China, as our story has been
published in both the print and the website of China Daily, and it has been
reposted by more than 10 famous media outlets, including People's Daily,
China Radio International, NetEase, Taiwan News, Jimu News, AsiaNet, China
Culture, News Reader, along with some related website such as China Music
Education Network and China Vision, a UK charity organization.
To cater to the learning demands of visually impaired and severely myopic
pupils, we have compatible with reading mode feature into our Wiki page,
providing visually challenged students auditory access to the contents.
With a simple click, the page converts text into speech, allowing visually
challenged students to learn by listening.
Braille Picture Books
We have put a lot of effort into developing Braille picture books for
biology, addressing the educational requirements of visually impaired
students. These books offer a more intuitive and engaging means for
visually challenged students to delve into the world of biology through
Braille. Complex concepts such as cells and DNA become comprehensible
through tactile exploration, enhancing the enjoyment and effectiveness of
the learning process.
This experiential learning approach can not only spark the enthusiasm of
the visually impaired for studying science. It can also provide them with a
profound understanding of the essence of science. Furthermore, it can help
bolster their self-confidence by offering them a window into the realm of
science. This creative teaching method not only inspires blind students to
be more active and involved in their education but also raises awareness of
the academic needs to support visually impaired students. It underscores
the significance of accommodating diverse learning styles and fostering an
inclusive educational environment.
We have composed biology-themed songs with catchy melodies and lyrics that
incorporate scientific knowledge. These innovative songs allow visually
impaired students to easily memorize scientific content through their sense
of hearing. This creative learning approach aims to nurture their interest
in science and inspire their curiosity for future exploration.
As the team members had little prior exposure to the visually impaired
community, we organized an activity called "One Hour in Darkness". Taking
into consideration both amusement and safety in the activity, participants
were required to complete various tasks with a blindfold.
The event aimed to boost awareness among the participants of the challenges
faced by the visually impaired community. The activity involved initiatives
such as improving tactile pathways, enhancing accessibility facilities, and
using technology to aid their integration. Additionally, the event
successfully educated young individuals about vision preservation, healthy
eye habits. It also aimed to inspire volunteerism, combat biases and
empower the visually impaired.
In the first stage, students cooperated in pairs, with one blindfolded,
walking, and the other providing guidance to navigate potential hazards on
the ground.
This task may seem simple, but the students lacked experience in walking in
the dark. On-site feedback revealed that blindfolded students generally
lacked a sense of security, and some felt uneasy. Every step forward seemed
to be accompanied by a sense of inner struggle, but they eventually
completed the task with the assistance of their partners.
In the second stage, blindfolded participants attempted to walk in a
straight line, which initially seemed easy. However, without their vision,
they walked clumsily, deviating from the path and stumbling. This
highlights how our brains rely on visual input for walking adjustments. To
adapt, students explored alternatives navigation signs such as sound cues
and tactile feedback, which challenged their balance and coordination,
emphasizing the significance of vision for movement.
In the third stage, "Opening Blind Boxes," groups of three participants
reached into boxes to identify differences based on size, shape, and
weight. The absence of sight heightened their fear of the unknown, causing
unease even with ordinary food items such as tofu, winter melon, and loach.
This experience deepened their empathy for the visually impaired community
and underscored the need for an accessible and inclusive environment in
daily life.
In the final game, "Blindfolded Hide-and-Seek," three students acted as
"seekers" while blindfolded, and the others evaded them within a designated
area. The blindfolded participants relied on hearing to locate others and
used their hands to gauge distance, all while navigating carefully. This
experience enabled participants to grasp the challenges and bravery of
living with visual impairment, fostering a deeper appreciation for the
needs of visually impaired individuals.
Through this series of blindfolded games, students could develop a deep
understanding of the real lives and daily challenges faced by the visually
impaired community. The event helped eliminate any biases they may have
had, deepens their perception of the world, and sparked their interest in
caring for the visually impaired community.
One of the participants said, "Even though it was just a few minutes of
being blindfolded, it generated a lot of fear and discomfort in me. It's
really tough for the visually impaired community to move around. As a
teenager, I will cherish my current living conditions and cultivate good
eye habits. I also hope that I can do something for the visually impaired
community."
We have written articles on our official WeChat account, introducing the
lives of notable blind scientists such as Louis Braille and Geerat J.
Vermeij. And we have created display boards showcasing the achievements of
renowned blind scientists from history, with the aim of inspiring young
visually impaired individuals to pursue careers in science. This initiative
has also encouraged increased public awareness and inclusivity toward the
visually impaired community.
We have developed "Glimmer Lab," an Audio-accessible interactive game designed to simulate biological scientific experiments, enabling visually impaired students to experience laboratory settings and engage in scientific exploration. Through this online game, individuals with visual impairments can simulate immersive scientific experiments using sound interaction and screen clicking, for example, clicking the mouse to weigh 2 grams of coarse salt on a tray balance. This allows them to expand their knowledge through auditory cues, providing an engaging and educational experience. The game includes three experiments: the reaction between sodium and water, crude salt purification, and agarose gel electrophoresis.
The entire interface is presented against a black background, and the illustrations utilize vibrant, saturated colors to heighten visual contrast. This design is intended to offer color-enhancement benefits to individuals with partial visual impairments, enabling them to more effectively discern the reactions and colors of the elements. This novel tool is designed to bridge the gap in science education for visually impaired students. The audio game allows students to navigate virtual laboratories, conduct experiments, and immerse themselves in lifelike lab settings through auditory cues. Despite the absence of visual clues, visually challenged students can use virtual equipment to conduct experiments, gaining practical skills and insights. These tools may also aid blind students and researchers by promoting inclusivity and collaboration in scientific research and teaching.
After eight months of dedicated effort, our team's mission is to help
remove the "invisible" barriers to science education for the visually
impaired, inspiring them to pursue their passions in the realm of science
through the initiatives we've outlined. We take great pride in the belief
that our endeavors will empower visually impaired individuals to unleash
their potential in the field of science, inspiring them to pursue careers
in this domain.
Through our collective efforts, we aspire to transform the realm of science
into a more inclusive domain, where everyone enjoys equal opportunities to
participate and contribute to the creation of a brighter world. We are
confident that by promoting inclusive education and innovative learning
methods, we will ignite the spark of scientific curiosity in every
inquisitive mind, thereby illuminating our world through the power of
inclusivity.
Additionally, we hope that the products we've created, such as the
laboratory game and Braille picture books, will leave a lasting impression
and continue to be valuable resources for years to come.
Reference
[1] World Health Organization (WHO). (2019). World Report on Vision.
https://www.who.int/publications/i/item/world-report-on-vision
[2] Myopia in Chinese Adolescents: Its Influencing Factors and Correlation
with Physical Activities
Yao Yin, 1 Cheng Qiu,corresponding author 2 and Yufei Qicorresponding
author 3
https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC9433230/
[3] Early care for childhood myopia called key
https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/a/202306/15/WS648a3b02a31033ad3f7bc479.html